The Papers
Browse the PapersDocumentsJournalsAdministrative RecordsRevelations and TranslationsHistoriesLegal RecordsFinancial RecordsOther Contemporary Papers
Reference
PeoplePlacesEventsGlossaryLegal GlossaryFinancial GlossaryCalendar of DocumentsWorks CitedFeatured TopicsLesson PlansRelated Publications
Media
VideosPhotographsIllustrationsChartsMapsPodcasts
News
Current NewsArchiveNewsletterSubscribeJSP Conferences
About
About the ProjectJoseph Smith and His PapersFAQAwardsEndorsementsReviewsEditorial MethodNote on TranscriptionsNote on Images of People and PlacesReferencing the ProjectCiting This WebsiteProject TeamContact Us
Published Volumes
  1. Home > 
  2. The Papers > 

Letter to John C. Calhoun, 2 January 1844

Source Note

JS, Letter,
Nauvoo

Principal gathering place for Saints following expulsion from Missouri. Beginning in 1839, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints purchased lands in earlier settlement of Commerce and planned settlement of Commerce City, as well as surrounding areas....

More Info
, Hancock Co., IL, to
John C. Calhoun

18 Mar. 1782–31 Mar. 1850. Lawyer, politician. Born near Hutchinson’s Mill, Ninety-Sixth District (later Calhoun Mill, Mount Carmel, McCormick Co.), South Carolina. Son of Patrick Calhoun and Martha Caldwell. Graduated from Yale, 1804, in New Haven, New Haven...

View Full Bio
, Fort Hill, Pickens Co., SC, 2 Jan. 1844. Featured version published in Times and Seasons, 1 Jan. 1844, vol. 5, no. 1, 394–396. For more complete source information, see the source note for Letter to Isaac Galland, 22 Mar. 1839.

Historical Introduction

On 2 January 1844, JS wrote a reply to
John C. Calhoun

18 Mar. 1782–31 Mar. 1850. Lawyer, politician. Born near Hutchinson’s Mill, Ninety-Sixth District (later Calhoun Mill, Mount Carmel, McCormick Co.), South Carolina. Son of Patrick Calhoun and Martha Caldwell. Graduated from Yale, 1804, in New Haven, New Haven...

View Full Bio
in which he debated Calhoun’s opinions on the federal government’s role in protecting religious minorities. Calhoun was a prominent politician from
South Carolina

One of original thirteen states that formed U.S. Settled at Port Royal, 1670. Separated from North Carolina and organized under royal government, 1719. Admitted as state, 1788. Population in 1830 about 581,000. Population in 1840 about 594,000. JS exchanged...

More Info
who had served in both chambers of the
United States

North American constitutional republic. Constitution ratified, 17 Sept. 1787. Population in 1805 about 6,000,000; in 1830 about 13,000,000; and in 1844 about 20,000,000. Louisiana Purchase, 1803, doubled size of U.S. Consisted of seventeen states at time ...

More Info
Congress and as vice president to both
John Quincy Adams

11 July 1767–23 Feb. 1848. Lawyer, diplomat, politician. Born in Braintree (later in Quincy), Suffolk Co., Massachusetts. Son of John Adams and Abigail Smith. Lived alternately in Braintree and Boston, from 1772. Studied law at Harvard University. Married...

View Full Bio
and Andrew Jackson.
1

Biographical Directory of the United States Congress, 770.


Comprehensive Works Cited

Biographical Directory of the United States Congress, 1774–1989: The Continental Congress September 5, 1774, to October 21, 1788, and the Congress of the United States from the First through the One Hundredth Congresses March 4, 1789, to January 3, 1989, Inclusive. Edited by Kathryn Allamong Jacob and Bruce A. Ragsdale. Washington DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1989.

JS and Calhoun first met in 1839 or 1840 when JS was in
Washington DC

Created as district for seat of U.S. federal government by act of Congress, 1790, and named Washington DC, 1791. Named in honor of George Washington. Headquarters of executive, legislative, and judicial branches of U.S. government relocated to Washington ...

More Info
to petition the United States Senate for redress and reparations for the property
church

The Book of Mormon related that when Christ set up his church in the Americas, “they which were baptized in the name of Jesus, were called the church of Christ.” The first name used to denote the church JS organized on 6 April 1830 was “the Church of Christ...

View Glossary
members had lost in
Missouri

Area acquired by U.S. in Louisiana Purchase, 1803, and established as territory, 1812. Missouri Compromise, 1820, admitted Missouri as slave state, 1821. Population in 1830 about 140,000; in 1836 about 240,000; and in 1840 about 380,000. Latter-day Saint ...

More Info
during the 1830s. Calhoun apparently declined to support the church’s petitioning efforts at that time.
2

Letter from John C. Calhoun, 2 Dec. 1843; see also Letter to Hyrum Smith and Nauvoo High Council, 5 Dec. 1839.


In November 1843, JS wrote to Calhoun and four other prospective presidential candidates to ask, “What will be your rule of action, relative to us, as a people, should fortune favor your ascension to the Chief Magistracy?”
3

Letter to John C. Calhoun, 4 Nov. 1843, underlining in original; see also JS, Draft Letter to Presidential Candidates, 4 Nov. 1843, JS Collection, CHL. The other prospective candidates to whom JS wrote were Lewis Cass, Henry Clay, Richard M. Johnson, and Martin Van Buren.


Calhoun responded to JS’s letter on 2 December 1843. He explained that, as president, he would give all men and women equal protection under the law regardless of religious affiliation, but he stated that, in his opinion, the Latter-day Saints’ case “does not come within the Jurisdiction of the Federal government, which is one of limited and specific powers.”
4

Letter from John C. Calhoun, 2 Dec. 1843.


Calhoun’s response was similar in tone and substance to that of
Lewis Cass

9 Oct. 1782–17 June 1866. Teacher, lawyer, soldier, author, politician. Born in Exeter, Rockingham Co., New Hampshire. Son of Jonathan Cass and Mary Gilman. Attended Phillips Academy, 1792–1799, in Exeter, where he also taught. Teacher in Wilmington, New ...

View Full Bio
, another presidential hopeful. Cass wrote to JS, “I do not see what power, the President of the United States can have over the matter, or how he can interfere in it.”
5

Letter from Lewis Cass, 9 Dec. 1843.


On 27 December 1843, JS assigned one of his clerks,
William W. Phelps

17 Feb. 1792–7 Mar. 1872. Writer, teacher, printer, newspaper editor, publisher, postmaster, lawyer. Born at Hanover, Morris Co., New Jersey. Son of Enon Phelps and Mehitabel Goldsmith. Moved to Homer, Cortland Co., New York, 1800. Married Sally Waterman,...

View Full Bio
, to draft responses to
Calhoun

18 Mar. 1782–31 Mar. 1850. Lawyer, politician. Born near Hutchinson’s Mill, Ninety-Sixth District (later Calhoun Mill, Mount Carmel, McCormick Co.), South Carolina. Son of Patrick Calhoun and Martha Caldwell. Graduated from Yale, 1804, in New Haven, New Haven...

View Full Bio
and
Cass

9 Oct. 1782–17 June 1866. Teacher, lawyer, soldier, author, politician. Born in Exeter, Rockingham Co., New Hampshire. Son of Jonathan Cass and Mary Gilman. Attended Phillips Academy, 1792–1799, in Exeter, where he also taught. Teacher in Wilmington, New ...

View Full Bio
and instructed him on the content of those replies.
6

JS, Journal, 27 Dec. 1843. If Phelps drafted a response to Cass, that letter is not extant. Because Cass’s reply echoed Calhoun’s and because JS apparently intended to publish the response to Calhoun as an open letter, a response to Cass may have been deemed superfluous. (McBride, Joseph Smith for President, 84–87.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

McBride, Spencer W. Joseph Smith for President: The Prophet, the Assassins, and the Fight for American Religious Freedom. New York: Oxford University Press, 2021.

Phelps apparently drafted the letter sometime over the next week. He dated the response to Calhoun 2 January 1844, which suggests that JS had reviewed and approved the letter by that date.
7

JS, Nauvoo, IL, to John C. Calhoun, Fort Hill, SC, 2 Jan. 1844, draft, JS Collection, CHL.


On 5 January, JS invited Phelps to read him the response.
8

JS, Journal, 5 Jan. 1844.


The letter frequently quotes passages of
Calhoun

18 Mar. 1782–31 Mar. 1850. Lawyer, politician. Born near Hutchinson’s Mill, Ninety-Sixth District (later Calhoun Mill, Mount Carmel, McCormick Co.), South Carolina. Son of Patrick Calhoun and Martha Caldwell. Graduated from Yale, 1804, in New Haven, New Haven...

View Full Bio
’s December 1843 letter and then rebuts Calhoun’s ideas. JS argued that the devotion of Calhoun and other members of Congress to the philosophy of states’ rights negatively affected religious minorities in the
United States

North American constitutional republic. Constitution ratified, 17 Sept. 1787. Population in 1805 about 6,000,000; in 1830 about 13,000,000; and in 1844 about 20,000,000. Louisiana Purchase, 1803, doubled size of U.S. Consisted of seventeen states at time ...

More Info
. He asserted that without a federal government empowered to redress the persecution of such groups within individual states, mobs would continue to persecute religious minorities without legal consequences. JS maintained that the remedy was a strong federal government enabled to intervene on behalf of such groups.
JS does not appear to have sent the letter directly to
Calhoun

18 Mar. 1782–31 Mar. 1850. Lawyer, politician. Born near Hutchinson’s Mill, Ninety-Sixth District (later Calhoun Mill, Mount Carmel, McCormick Co.), South Carolina. Son of Patrick Calhoun and Martha Caldwell. Graduated from Yale, 1804, in New Haven, New Haven...

View Full Bio
but rather had it published as an open letter to Calhoun in the
Nauvoo

Principal gathering place for Saints following expulsion from Missouri. Beginning in 1839, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints purchased lands in earlier settlement of Commerce and planned settlement of Commerce City, as well as surrounding areas....

More Info
newspapers. It was published in the 1 January 1844 issue of the Times and Seasons, which was evidently published after 2 January, and in the 10 January issue of the Nauvoo Neighbor.
9

“Correspondence of Gen. Joseph Smith and Hon. J. C. Calhoun,” Nauvoo Neighbor, 10 Jan. 1844, [2]–[3]. The inclusion of this 2 January letter in the 1 January 1844 issue of the Times and Seasons indicates that the issue was published sometime after the issue date.


Several newspapers reprinted the text of the letter, including the Niles’ National Register—a prominent national newspaper published in
Baltimore

City located on north side of Patapsco River about forty miles northeast of Washington DC. Laid out as town, 1729. Received city charter, 1797. Population in 1830 about 80,600. Population in 1840 about 102,300. David S. Hollister wrote to JS from Baltimore...

More Info
—which featured the letter in its 3 February 1844 issue.
10

“Correspondence of Gen. Jos. Smith and Hon. J. C. Calhoun,” Niles’ National Register (Baltimore), 3 Feb. 1844, 357–358.


Comprehensive Works Cited

Niles’ National Register. Washington DC, 1837–1839; Baltimore, 1839–1848; Philadelphia, 1848–1849.

JS retained a draft of the letter written by
Phelps

17 Feb. 1792–7 Mar. 1872. Writer, teacher, printer, newspaper editor, publisher, postmaster, lawyer. Born at Hanover, Morris Co., New Jersey. Son of Enon Phelps and Mehitabel Goldsmith. Moved to Homer, Cortland Co., New York, 1800. Married Sally Waterman,...

View Full Bio
and a copy made by
Thomas Bullock

23 Dec. 1816–10 Feb. 1885. Farmer, excise officer, secretary, clerk. Born in Leek, Staffordshire, England. Son of Thomas Bullock and Mary Hall. Married Henrietta Rushton, 25 June 1838. Moved to Ardee, Co. Louth, Ireland, Nov. 1839; to Isle of Anglesey, Aug...

View Full Bio
.
11

JS, Nauvoo, IL, to John C. Calhoun, Fort Hill, SC, 2 Jan. 1844, draft; JS, Nauvoo, IL, to John C. Calhoun, Fort Hill, SC, 2 Jan. 1844, copy, JS Collection, CHL.


Because JS apparently intended the letter to be a public response to Calhoun, the version from the Times and Seasons is featured here as the earliest published version of the letter. There is no known response from Calhoun.

Footnotes

  1. [1]

    Biographical Directory of the United States Congress, 770.

    Biographical Directory of the United States Congress, 1774–1989: The Continental Congress September 5, 1774, to October 21, 1788, and the Congress of the United States from the First through the One Hundredth Congresses March 4, 1789, to January 3, 1989, Inclusive. Edited by Kathryn Allamong Jacob and Bruce A. Ragsdale. Washington DC: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1989.

  2. [2]

    Letter from John C. Calhoun, 2 Dec. 1843; see also Letter to Hyrum Smith and Nauvoo High Council, 5 Dec. 1839.

  3. [3]

    Letter to John C. Calhoun, 4 Nov. 1843, underlining in original; see also JS, Draft Letter to Presidential Candidates, 4 Nov. 1843, JS Collection, CHL. The other prospective candidates to whom JS wrote were Lewis Cass, Henry Clay, Richard M. Johnson, and Martin Van Buren.

  4. [4]

    Letter from John C. Calhoun, 2 Dec. 1843.

  5. [5]

    Letter from Lewis Cass, 9 Dec. 1843.

  6. [6]

    JS, Journal, 27 Dec. 1843. If Phelps drafted a response to Cass, that letter is not extant. Because Cass’s reply echoed Calhoun’s and because JS apparently intended to publish the response to Calhoun as an open letter, a response to Cass may have been deemed superfluous. (McBride, Joseph Smith for President, 84–87.)

    McBride, Spencer W. Joseph Smith for President: The Prophet, the Assassins, and the Fight for American Religious Freedom. New York: Oxford University Press, 2021.

  7. [7]

    JS, Nauvoo, IL, to John C. Calhoun, Fort Hill, SC, 2 Jan. 1844, draft, JS Collection, CHL.

  8. [8]

    JS, Journal, 5 Jan. 1844.

  9. [9]

    “Correspondence of Gen. Joseph Smith and Hon. J. C. Calhoun,” Nauvoo Neighbor, 10 Jan. 1844, [2]–[3]. The inclusion of this 2 January letter in the 1 January 1844 issue of the Times and Seasons indicates that the issue was published sometime after the issue date.

  10. [10]

    “Correspondence of Gen. Jos. Smith and Hon. J. C. Calhoun,” Niles’ National Register (Baltimore), 3 Feb. 1844, 357–358.

    Niles’ National Register. Washington DC, 1837–1839; Baltimore, 1839–1848; Philadelphia, 1848–1849.

  11. [11]

    JS, Nauvoo, IL, to John C. Calhoun, Fort Hill, SC, 2 Jan. 1844, draft; JS, Nauvoo, IL, to John C. Calhoun, Fort Hill, SC, 2 Jan. 1844, copy, JS Collection, CHL.

Asterisk (*) denotes a "featured" version, which includes an introduction and annotation. Letter to John C. Calhoun, 2 January 1844, Draft Letter to John C. Calhoun, 2 January 1844, Thomas Bullock Copy *Letter to John C. Calhoun, 2 January 1844 Letter to John C. Calhoun, 2 January 1844, as Published in Nauvoo Neighbor Letter to John C. Calhoun, 2 January 1844, as Published in New York Herald History, 1838–1856, volume E-1 [1 July 1843–30 April 1844] “History of Joseph Smith”

Page 395

hand of Russian grasp;
8

This is likely a reference to the exile of Polish soldiers in the aftermath of the Polish Uprising of 1830–1831. When the Poles realized that their revolution against the Russian Empire would fail, thousands of soldiers, officers, and dignitaries fled to western Europe, where they lived in self-imposed exile rather than surrender to the Russian Army and face punishment from Tsar Nicholas I. (Urbanik and Baylen, “Polish Exiles and the Turkish Empire, 1830–1876,” 43.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Urbanik, Andrew A., and Joseph O. Baylen. “Polish Exiles and the Turkish Empire, 1830–1876.” Polish Review 26, no. 3 (1981): 43–53.

ye poor and unfortunate among all nations, come to the ‘asylum of the oppressed;’
9

In 1772 Joseph Warren popularized the phrase “asylum of the oppressed” to describe the British colonies in North America. (Bostonian [pseud.], Biographical Sketch of Gen. Joseph Warren, 32.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Biographical Sketch of Gen. Joseph Warren, Embracing the Prominent Events of His Life, and His Boston Orations of 1772 and 1775; together with the Celebrated Eulogy Pronounced by Perez Morton, M. M., on the Re­interment of the Remains by the Masonic Order, at King’s Chapel, in 1776. Boston: Shepard, Clark, and Brown, 1857.

buy ye lands of the general government, pay in your money to the treasury to strengthen the army and the navy; worship God according to the dictates of your own consciences; pay in your taxes to support the great heads of a glorious nation; but remember a ‘sovereign state!’ is so much more powerful than the
United States

North American constitutional republic. Constitution ratified, 17 Sept. 1787. Population in 1805 about 6,000,000; in 1830 about 13,000,000; and in 1844 about 20,000,000. Louisiana Purchase, 1803, doubled size of U.S. Consisted of seventeen states at time ...

More Info
, the parent government, that it can exile you at pleasure, mob you with impunity; confiscate your lands and property; have the legislature sanction it: yea, even murder you, as an edict of an Emperor,
10

This is likely a reference to Missouri governor Lilburn W. Boggs, who ordered the expulsion of the Latter-day Saints from Missouri in 1838 under threat of extermination. (Lilburn W. Boggs, Jefferson City, MO, to John B. Clark, Fayette, MO, 27 Oct. 1838, Mormon War Papers, Missouri State Archives, Jefferson City.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Records of Governor Thomas Reynolds, 1840–1844. MSA.

and it does no wrong, for the noble
senator

18 Mar. 1782–31 Mar. 1850. Lawyer, politician. Born near Hutchinson’s Mill, Ninety-Sixth District (later Calhoun Mill, Mount Carmel, McCormick Co.), South Carolina. Son of Patrick Calhoun and Martha Caldwell. Graduated from Yale, 1804, in New Haven, New Haven...

View Full Bio
of
South Carolina

One of original thirteen states that formed U.S. Settled at Port Royal, 1670. Separated from North Carolina and organized under royal government, 1719. Admitted as state, 1788. Population in 1830 about 581,000. Population in 1840 about 594,000. JS exchanged...

More Info
, says the power of the federal government is so limited and specific that it has no jurisdiction of the case! What think ye of Imperium in imperio.
11

Imperium in imperio is Latin for “empire within an empire.” JS was referring to the division of power in the federal system and the Constitution’s federal supremacy clause. (U.S. Constitution, art. 6, clause 2; see also Rogers, Unpopular Sovereignty, 30.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Rogers, Brent M. Unpopular Sovereignty: Mormons and the Federal Management of Early Utah Territory. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2017.

Ye spirits of the blessed of all ages, hark! Ye shades of departed statesmen, listen! Abraham, Moses, Homer, Socrates, Solon, Solomon, and all that ever thought of right and wrong, look down from your exaltations, if you have any, for it is said in the midst of counsellors there is safety,
12

See Proverbs 11:14.


and when you have learned that fifteen thousand innocent citizens after having purchased their lands of the
United States

North American constitutional republic. Constitution ratified, 17 Sept. 1787. Population in 1805 about 6,000,000; in 1830 about 13,000,000; and in 1844 about 20,000,000. Louisiana Purchase, 1803, doubled size of U.S. Consisted of seventeen states at time ...

More Info
, and paid for them, were expelled from a ‘
sovereign state

Area acquired by U.S. in Louisiana Purchase, 1803, and established as territory, 1812. Missouri Compromise, 1820, admitted Missouri as slave state, 1821. Population in 1830 about 140,000; in 1836 about 240,000; and in 1840 about 380,000. Latter-day Saint ...

More Info
’ by order of the
governor

14 Dec. 1796–14 Mar. 1860. Bookkeeper, bank cashier, merchant, Indian agent and trader, lawyer, doctor, postmaster, politician. Born at Lexington, Fayette Co., Kentucky. Son of John M. Boggs and Martha Oliver. Served in War of 1812. Moved to St. Louis, ca...

View Full Bio
, at the point of the bayonet; their arms taken from them by the same authority:
13

The Missouri state militia seized the weapons of Latter-day Saints at Far West, Missouri, on 1 November 1838. (Corrill, Brief History, 42–43.)


and their right of migration into said
state

Area acquired by U.S. in Louisiana Purchase, 1803, and established as territory, 1812. Missouri Compromise, 1820, admitted Missouri as slave state, 1821. Population in 1830 about 140,000; in 1836 about 240,000; and in 1840 about 380,000. Latter-day Saint ...

More Info
, denied under pain of imprisonment, whipping, robbing, mobbing, and even death, and no justice or recompence allowed; and from the legislature, with the
governor

14 Dec. 1796–14 Mar. 1860. Bookkeeper, bank cashier, merchant, Indian agent and trader, lawyer, doctor, postmaster, politician. Born at Lexington, Fayette Co., Kentucky. Son of John M. Boggs and Martha Oliver. Served in War of 1812. Moved to St. Louis, ca...

View Full Bio
at the head, down to the
justice of the peace

11 Sept. 1801–14 July 1890. Farmer, sheriff, justice of the peace, judge. Born at Henderson Co., Kentucky. Son of William Black and Jane Wilson. Moved near Booneville, Copper Co., Missouri Territory, and then to Ray Co., Missouri Territory, 1819. Elected ...

View Full Bio
, with a bottle of whiskey in one hand, and a bowie knife in the other, hear them all declare that there is no justice for a Mormon in that
state

Area acquired by U.S. in Louisiana Purchase, 1803, and established as territory, 1812. Missouri Compromise, 1820, admitted Missouri as slave state, 1821. Population in 1830 about 140,000; in 1836 about 240,000; and in 1840 about 380,000. Latter-day Saint ...

More Info
, and judge ye a righteous judgment, and tell me when the virtue of the states was stolen; where the honor of the general government lies hid; and what clothes a senator with wisdom? Oh nullifying
Carolina

One of original thirteen states that formed U.S. Settled at Port Royal, 1670. Separated from North Carolina and organized under royal government, 1719. Admitted as state, 1788. Population in 1830 about 581,000. Population in 1840 about 594,000. JS exchanged...

More Info
!
14

This is a reference to the Nullification Crisis, which occurred in 1832–1833 when the government of South Carolina declared its intention to disregard the federal tariffs of 1828 and 1832. South Carolina’s actions sparked a debate over the ability of individual states to nullify federal law. President Andrew Jackson claimed that states could not nullify federal law and prepared to lead the United States Army to South Carolina to enforce it, if necessary. Calhoun was one of the leading proponents of South Carolina’s actions. (Howe, What Hath God Wrought, 401–410.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Howe, Daniel Walker. What Hath God Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815–1848. The Oxford History of the United States. New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

—Oh little tempestuous
Rhode Island

One of original thirteen states that formed U.S. Settled at Providence by Roger Williams, 1636. Charter originally granted by Charles II, 1663. Admitted as thirteenth state, 1790. Population in 1830 about 97,000. Population in 1840 about 109,000. Home to ...

More Info
!
15

This is likely a reference to the Dorr Rebellion in Rhode Island. Starting in 1841, Thomas Wilson Dorr led a movement to revise Rhode Island’s 1663 colonial charter, which limited voting to men who owned property valued at $134 or more. Dorr called for suffrage for all white males, and his supporters established a new state government that rivaled the duly elected state government. In spring 1842, Rhode Island governor Samuel Ward King declared martial law and requested federal troops to defend the state’s arsenal from a raid Dorr and his supporters were planning. Dorr’s rebellion ultimately failed, but for many Americans it symbolized the people’s right to alter and amend their forms of government when the majority deemed it necessary to do so. (Chaput, People’s Martyr, 1–11, chaps. 3–5.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Chaput, Erik J. The People’s Martyr: Thomas Wilson Dorr and His 1842 Rhode Island Rebellion. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 2013.

would it not be well for the great men of the nation to read the fable of the partial judge,
16

“The Partial Judge” is one of Aesop’s fables. In it, a farmer informs a lawyer that his bull killed one of the lawyer’s oxen and that he would like to make reparations. The lawyer praises the farmer for his honesty. When the farmer reveals that it was actually the lawyer’s bull that killed one of the farmer’s oxen, the lawyer asks for an investigation before considering paying reparations. (Dodsley, Select Fables of Aesop, 106.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Dodsley, R. Select Fables of Aesop and Other Fabulists, in Three Books. New ed. London: Henry Mozley, 1809.

and when part of the free citizens of a state had been expelled contrary to the constitution, mobbed, robbed, plundered and many murdered, instead of searching into the course taken with Joanna, Southcott,
17

Starting around 1792 in Exeter, England, Joanna Southcott began prophesying, and she eventually declared that she was the woman described in the twelfth chapter of Revelation who would give birth to a son “who was to rule all nations with a rod of iron.” Southcott was harshly criticized in English newspapers. She died in 1814, but her followers sustained a religious movement through the end of the nineteenth century. (Revelation 12:1–5; see also Hopkins, Woman to Deliver Her People, 17–20, 199–217.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Hopkins, James K. A Woman to Deliver Her People: Joanna Southcott and English Millenar- ianism in an Era of Revolution. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1982.

Ann Lee,
18

Lee was the founder of the United Society of Believers in Christ’s Second Appearing, a group also known as the Shakers. In 1774 she led her followers from England to New York, where they established an egalitarian community. The Shakers occasionally experienced persecution in the form of mob violence. Lee and the Shakers were pacifists and therefore refused to support the American Revolution. She and other Shaker leaders were arrested in 1780. (See Stein, Shaker Experience in America, 1–38.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Stein, Stephen J. The Shaker Experience in America: A History of the United Society of Believers. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1992.

the French prophets,
19

The French Prophets were a millenarian group of prophets who left France for England in the early eighteenth century and preached that the second coming of Jesus Christ was imminent. The group attracted more than five hundred followers in the first half of the eighteenth century. Many group members were subjected to mob violence in England. (See Schwartz, French Prophets, chap. 3.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Schwartz, Hillel. The French Prophets: The History of a Millenarian Group in Eighteenth-Century England. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980.

the Quakers of New England,
20

The first Quakers to arrive in the New England colonies were Mary Fisher and Ann Austin. Shortly after they reached the Massachusetts Bay Colony in the mid-seventeenth century, they were persecuted for their beliefs. Other Quakers followed Fisher and Austin, and the colony banished many of them. Eventually, most of the Quakers in Massachusetts resettled in the more tolerant colony of Rhode Island. (See Hamm, Quakers in America, 22–24.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Hamm, Thomas D. The Quakers in America. New York: Columbia University Press, 2003.

and rebellious niggers,
21

This racial slur was commonly employed by white Americans by the nineteenth century to refer derogatorily to people of African descent. Black Americans strongly objected to the use of the term. The Church Historian’s Press also condemns the use of this word but retains it in document transcripts to accurately present the historical record and to illuminate the oppressive racial landscape faced by Black Americans. (Easton, Treatise on the Intellectual Character, and Civil and Political Condition of the Colored People of the U. States, 40–41.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Easton, Hosea. A Treatise on the Intellectual Character, and Civil and Political Condition of the Colored People of the U. States; and the Prejudice Exercised towards Them: With a Sermon on the Duty of the Church to Them. Boston: Isaac Knapp, 1837.

in the slave states,
22

Slave rebellions occurred occasionally in the United States during the nineteenth century. The best-known slave rebellion at this time was Nat Turner’s Rebellion, which took place in Virginia in 1831. (See Sinha, Slave’s Cause, 57–59.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Sinha, Manisha. The Slave’s Cause: A History of Abolition. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2016.

to hear both sides and then judge, rather than have the mortification to say, ‘oh it is my bull that has killed your ox, that alters the case! I must enquire into it, and if, and if?’
23

This is a reference to the hypocritical response of the lawyer at the conclusion of the fable “The Partial Judge.” (Dodsley, Select Fables of Aesop, 106.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Dodsley, R. Select Fables of Aesop and Other Fabulists, in Three Books. New ed. London: Henry Mozley, 1809.

If the general government has no power to reinstate expelled citizens to their rights, there is a monstrous hypocrite fed and fostered from the hard earnings of the people! A real ‘bull beggar’ upheld by sycophants; and, although you may wink to the priests to stigmatize;— wheedle the drunkards to swear, and raise the hue and cry of imposter false prophet, God damn old Joe Smith, yet remember, if the
Latter Day Saints

The Book of Mormon related that when Christ set up his church in the Americas, “they which were baptized in the name of Jesus, were called the church of Christ.” The first name used to denote the church JS organized on 6 April 1830 was “the Church of Christ...

View Glossary
are not restored to all their rights, and paid for all their losses, according to the known rules of justice and judgment, reciprocation and common honesty among men, that God will come out of his hiding place and vex this nation with a sore vexation
24

See Revelation, 16–17 Dec. 1833 [D&C 101:89].


—yea, the consuming wrath of an offended God shall smoke through the nation, with as much distress and woe, as independence has blazed through with pleasure and delight. Where is the strength of government? Where is the patriotism of a Washington, a Warren, and Adams? and where is a spark from the watch fire of ’76, by which one candle might be lit, that would glimmer upon the confines of democracy? Well may it be said that one man is not a state; nor one state the nation. In the days of General [Andrew] Jackson, when
France

Nation in western Europe. Paris chosen as capital, 508 AD. Political and economic crises led to revolution against monarchy, 1789. Napoleon Bonaparte crowned emperor in Paris, 1804. In 1815, Bonaparte abdicated after being defeated by British; monarchy restored...

More Info
refused the first instalment for spoliations, there was power, force, and honor enough to resent injustice and insult, and the money came:
25

During Jackson’s tenure as president, his envoys settled American spoliation claims worth over $7 million. These spoliations were based on American merchants’ losses dating back to the Napoleonic Wars, and most were charged against France. In 1835 the French government refused to pay the first installment. Jackson responded by threatening to send privateers to attack French commercial vessels. Some in Congress, including John Quincy Adams, began preparing for war. Ultimately, both sides found a diplomatic solution and averted violent conflict. The French government subsequently authorized the payment of the first installment. (Howe, What Hath God Wrought, 363.)


Comprehensive Works Cited

Howe, Daniel Walker. What Hath God Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815–1848. The Oxford History of the United States. New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

and shall
Missouri

Area acquired by U.S. in Louisiana Purchase, 1803, and established as territory, 1812. Missouri Compromise, 1820, admitted Missouri as slave state, 1821. Population in 1830 about 140,000; in 1836 about 240,000; and in 1840 about 380,000. Latter-day Saint ...

More Info
, filled with negro drivers, and white men stealers,
26

“White men stealers” may be a reference to the kidnappings of father and son Daniel and Philander Avery by Missourians in November and December 1843. (Affidavit from Daniel Avery, 28 Dec. 1843.)


go ‘unwhipped of justice,’
27

See Shakespeare, King Lear, act 3, sc. 2, line 53, in Wadsworth Shakespeare, 1323.


Comprehensive Works Cited

The Wadsworth Shakespeare, Formerly “The Riverside Shakespeare”: The Complete Works. Edited by G. Blakemore Evans, J. J. M. Tobin, Herschel Baker, Anne Barton, Frank Kermode, Harry Levin, Hallett Smith, and Marie Edel. 2nd ed. Boston: Wadsworth Cengage Learning, 1997.

for ten fold greater sins than
France

Nation in western Europe. Paris chosen as capital, 508 AD. Political and economic crises led to revolution against monarchy, 1789. Napoleon Bonaparte crowned emperor in Paris, 1804. In 1815, Bonaparte abdicated after being defeated by British; monarchy restored...

More Info
? No! verily no!—While I have powers of body and mind; while water runs and grass grows; while virtue is lovely, and vice hateful; and while a stone points out a sacred spot where a fragment of American liberty once was; I or my posterity will plead the cause of injured innocence, until
Missouri

Area acquired by U.S. in Louisiana Purchase, 1803, and established as territory, 1812. Missouri Compromise, 1820, admitted Missouri as slave state, 1821. Population in 1830 about 140,000; in 1836 about 240,000; and in 1840 about 380,000. Latter-day Saint ...

More Info
makes atonement for all her sins—or sinks disgraced, degraded and damned to hell—‘where the worm dieth not and the fire is not quenched.[’]
28

See Mark 9:44.


Why Sir, the power not delegated to the
United States

North American constitutional republic. Constitution ratified, 17 Sept. 1787. Population in 1805 about 6,000,000; in 1830 about 13,000,000; and in 1844 about 20,000,000. Louisiana Purchase, 1803, doubled size of U.S. Consisted of seventeen states at time ...

More Info
, and the states, belongs to the people,
29

See U.S. Constitution, amend. X.


and congress sent to do the people’s business, have all power—and shall fifteen thousand citizens groan in exile? Oh vain men, will ye not, if ye do not, restore them to their rights and $2,000,000 worth of property relinquish to them, (the Latter Day Saints) as a body, their portion of power that belongs to them acording to the constitution? Power has its convenience, as well as inconvenience.— ‘The world was not made for Caesar alone, but Titus too.’
I will give you a parable, A certain lord had a vineyard in a goodly land, which men labored in at their pleasure; for a few meek men also went [p. 395]
View entire transcript

|

Cite this page

Source Note

Document Transcript

Page 395

Document Information

Related Case Documents
Editorial Title
Letter to John C. Calhoun, 2 January 1844
ID #
10869
Total Pages
3
Print Volume Location
Handwriting on This Page
  • Printed text

Footnotes

  1. [8]

    This is likely a reference to the exile of Polish soldiers in the aftermath of the Polish Uprising of 1830–1831. When the Poles realized that their revolution against the Russian Empire would fail, thousands of soldiers, officers, and dignitaries fled to western Europe, where they lived in self-imposed exile rather than surrender to the Russian Army and face punishment from Tsar Nicholas I. (Urbanik and Baylen, “Polish Exiles and the Turkish Empire, 1830–1876,” 43.)

    Urbanik, Andrew A., and Joseph O. Baylen. “Polish Exiles and the Turkish Empire, 1830–1876.” Polish Review 26, no. 3 (1981): 43–53.

  2. [9]

    In 1772 Joseph Warren popularized the phrase “asylum of the oppressed” to describe the British colonies in North America. (Bostonian [pseud.], Biographical Sketch of Gen. Joseph Warren, 32.)

    Biographical Sketch of Gen. Joseph Warren, Embracing the Prominent Events of His Life, and His Boston Orations of 1772 and 1775; together with the Celebrated Eulogy Pronounced by Perez Morton, M. M., on the Re­interment of the Remains by the Masonic Order, at King’s Chapel, in 1776. Boston: Shepard, Clark, and Brown, 1857.

  3. [10]

    This is likely a reference to Missouri governor Lilburn W. Boggs, who ordered the expulsion of the Latter-day Saints from Missouri in 1838 under threat of extermination. (Lilburn W. Boggs, Jefferson City, MO, to John B. Clark, Fayette, MO, 27 Oct. 1838, Mormon War Papers, Missouri State Archives, Jefferson City.)

    Records of Governor Thomas Reynolds, 1840–1844. MSA.

  4. [11]

    Imperium in imperio is Latin for “empire within an empire.” JS was referring to the division of power in the federal system and the Constitution’s federal supremacy clause. (U.S. Constitution, art. 6, clause 2; see also Rogers, Unpopular Sovereignty, 30.)

    Rogers, Brent M. Unpopular Sovereignty: Mormons and the Federal Management of Early Utah Territory. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2017.

  5. [12]

    See Proverbs 11:14.

  6. [13]

    The Missouri state militia seized the weapons of Latter-day Saints at Far West, Missouri, on 1 November 1838. (Corrill, Brief History, 42–43.)

  7. [14]

    This is a reference to the Nullification Crisis, which occurred in 1832–1833 when the government of South Carolina declared its intention to disregard the federal tariffs of 1828 and 1832. South Carolina’s actions sparked a debate over the ability of individual states to nullify federal law. President Andrew Jackson claimed that states could not nullify federal law and prepared to lead the United States Army to South Carolina to enforce it, if necessary. Calhoun was one of the leading proponents of South Carolina’s actions. (Howe, What Hath God Wrought, 401–410.)

    Howe, Daniel Walker. What Hath God Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815–1848. The Oxford History of the United States. New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

  8. [15]

    This is likely a reference to the Dorr Rebellion in Rhode Island. Starting in 1841, Thomas Wilson Dorr led a movement to revise Rhode Island’s 1663 colonial charter, which limited voting to men who owned property valued at $134 or more. Dorr called for suffrage for all white males, and his supporters established a new state government that rivaled the duly elected state government. In spring 1842, Rhode Island governor Samuel Ward King declared martial law and requested federal troops to defend the state’s arsenal from a raid Dorr and his supporters were planning. Dorr’s rebellion ultimately failed, but for many Americans it symbolized the people’s right to alter and amend their forms of government when the majority deemed it necessary to do so. (Chaput, People’s Martyr, 1–11, chaps. 3–5.)

    Chaput, Erik J. The People’s Martyr: Thomas Wilson Dorr and His 1842 Rhode Island Rebellion. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas, 2013.

  9. [16]

    “The Partial Judge” is one of Aesop’s fables. In it, a farmer informs a lawyer that his bull killed one of the lawyer’s oxen and that he would like to make reparations. The lawyer praises the farmer for his honesty. When the farmer reveals that it was actually the lawyer’s bull that killed one of the farmer’s oxen, the lawyer asks for an investigation before considering paying reparations. (Dodsley, Select Fables of Aesop, 106.)

    Dodsley, R. Select Fables of Aesop and Other Fabulists, in Three Books. New ed. London: Henry Mozley, 1809.

  10. [17]

    Starting around 1792 in Exeter, England, Joanna Southcott began prophesying, and she eventually declared that she was the woman described in the twelfth chapter of Revelation who would give birth to a son “who was to rule all nations with a rod of iron.” Southcott was harshly criticized in English newspapers. She died in 1814, but her followers sustained a religious movement through the end of the nineteenth century. (Revelation 12:1–5; see also Hopkins, Woman to Deliver Her People, 17–20, 199–217.)

    Hopkins, James K. A Woman to Deliver Her People: Joanna Southcott and English Millenar- ianism in an Era of Revolution. Austin: University of Texas Press, 1982.

  11. [18]

    Lee was the founder of the United Society of Believers in Christ’s Second Appearing, a group also known as the Shakers. In 1774 she led her followers from England to New York, where they established an egalitarian community. The Shakers occasionally experienced persecution in the form of mob violence. Lee and the Shakers were pacifists and therefore refused to support the American Revolution. She and other Shaker leaders were arrested in 1780. (See Stein, Shaker Experience in America, 1–38.)

    Stein, Stephen J. The Shaker Experience in America: A History of the United Society of Believers. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1992.

  12. [19]

    The French Prophets were a millenarian group of prophets who left France for England in the early eighteenth century and preached that the second coming of Jesus Christ was imminent. The group attracted more than five hundred followers in the first half of the eighteenth century. Many group members were subjected to mob violence in England. (See Schwartz, French Prophets, chap. 3.)

    Schwartz, Hillel. The French Prophets: The History of a Millenarian Group in Eighteenth-Century England. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980.

  13. [20]

    The first Quakers to arrive in the New England colonies were Mary Fisher and Ann Austin. Shortly after they reached the Massachusetts Bay Colony in the mid-seventeenth century, they were persecuted for their beliefs. Other Quakers followed Fisher and Austin, and the colony banished many of them. Eventually, most of the Quakers in Massachusetts resettled in the more tolerant colony of Rhode Island. (See Hamm, Quakers in America, 22–24.)

    Hamm, Thomas D. The Quakers in America. New York: Columbia University Press, 2003.

  14. [21]

    This racial slur was commonly employed by white Americans by the nineteenth century to refer derogatorily to people of African descent. Black Americans strongly objected to the use of the term. The Church Historian’s Press also condemns the use of this word but retains it in document transcripts to accurately present the historical record and to illuminate the oppressive racial landscape faced by Black Americans. (Easton, Treatise on the Intellectual Character, and Civil and Political Condition of the Colored People of the U. States, 40–41.)

    Easton, Hosea. A Treatise on the Intellectual Character, and Civil and Political Condition of the Colored People of the U. States; and the Prejudice Exercised towards Them: With a Sermon on the Duty of the Church to Them. Boston: Isaac Knapp, 1837.

  15. [22]

    Slave rebellions occurred occasionally in the United States during the nineteenth century. The best-known slave rebellion at this time was Nat Turner’s Rebellion, which took place in Virginia in 1831. (See Sinha, Slave’s Cause, 57–59.)

    Sinha, Manisha. The Slave’s Cause: A History of Abolition. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2016.

  16. [23]

    This is a reference to the hypocritical response of the lawyer at the conclusion of the fable “The Partial Judge.” (Dodsley, Select Fables of Aesop, 106.)

    Dodsley, R. Select Fables of Aesop and Other Fabulists, in Three Books. New ed. London: Henry Mozley, 1809.

  17. [24]

    See Revelation, 16–17 Dec. 1833 [D&C 101:89].

  18. [25]

    During Jackson’s tenure as president, his envoys settled American spoliation claims worth over $7 million. These spoliations were based on American merchants’ losses dating back to the Napoleonic Wars, and most were charged against France. In 1835 the French government refused to pay the first installment. Jackson responded by threatening to send privateers to attack French commercial vessels. Some in Congress, including John Quincy Adams, began preparing for war. Ultimately, both sides found a diplomatic solution and averted violent conflict. The French government subsequently authorized the payment of the first installment. (Howe, What Hath God Wrought, 363.)

    Howe, Daniel Walker. What Hath God Wrought: The Transformation of America, 1815–1848. The Oxford History of the United States. New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

  19. [26]

    “White men stealers” may be a reference to the kidnappings of father and son Daniel and Philander Avery by Missourians in November and December 1843. (Affidavit from Daniel Avery, 28 Dec. 1843.)

  20. [27]

    See Shakespeare, King Lear, act 3, sc. 2, line 53, in Wadsworth Shakespeare, 1323.

    The Wadsworth Shakespeare, Formerly “The Riverside Shakespeare”: The Complete Works. Edited by G. Blakemore Evans, J. J. M. Tobin, Herschel Baker, Anne Barton, Frank Kermode, Harry Levin, Hallett Smith, and Marie Edel. 2nd ed. Boston: Wadsworth Cengage Learning, 1997.

  21. [28]

    See Mark 9:44.

  22. [29]

    See U.S. Constitution, amend. X.

© 2024 by Intellectual Reserve, Inc. All rights reserved.Terms of UseUpdated 2021-04-13Privacy NoticeUpdated 2021-04-06