History draft; handwriting of Jonathan Grimshaw, , , James Ure, and Robert L. Campbell; 76 numbered pages plus several inserted pages; CHL. This manuscript covers the period from 1 January 1844 to 21 June 1844.
Joseph Smith:— The statement I made out against , I have proved to be facts, and therefore it is not slander. I have testified boldly, and have brought witnesses to prove him to be an adulterer, and a vicious man. I did not do it until he began to use his evil influence against me. If I had been to blame, and he had got the least chance, he would have been here. He knows <I am> here, and all know that they have nothing against me. I have proved all that I ever testified; the Court would be bound to discharge me on account of having proved it. There are <very> few lawyers who know the great principle of the Act; ask a lawyer, and he does not know but that he has got to go to some judge. <The U. S. District> Judge () has been one of the Supreme Judges <of the >; his decision is that it is <should be> as much in the power of the simple Magistrate as of the greatest judge: hence Governors, and Supreme Judges all know that I am correct. A simple magistrate <should> has <have> the right; of <the right of> Habeas Corpus which shall not be denied, it does not say by a governor or Judge; who <then> does it mean? All the authorities. All judges know that it is a fact. If you hold the office of a magistrate, and you are sworn to keep inviolate the Constitution of the , you are sworn to fulfil that part which says that you shall not refuse the principle<benefit> <privilege> of the Habeas Corpus to any one. I have only to open Blackstone, or the Bible, and then I know where powers are. I never said anything about <the> Higbees <or the Laws or the Fosters> &c &c but what is strictly true. I have been placed in peculiar circumstances.
The only sin I ever committed was in <exercising sympathy> <&> covering up their iniquities; <*> <* or their<solemn> promises to reform> and that <of this> I am ashamed of, and never will do it <so> again. [p. 40a]